Document-20.    


BOBHSOC

The Sinking Of The Merchantman "Olivegrove"
September 7th 1939

With the knowledge of the embarrassment caused by the sinking of the Athenia just four days previous, Kapitänleutnant Hans-Wilhelm von Dresky commanding U-boat U33 on September 7th 1940, spotted  the merchantman, the 4,060 ton Olivegrove steaming about 400 miles south-west of Lands Ends in nor-nor-east direction at just under 10 knots. The Olivegrove was commanded by Captain James Barnetson and the ship was carrying a cargo of raw sugar from Cuba bound for Britain. The voyage across the Atlantic was an uneventful one and had been free from any enemy intervention until being spotted by the U33.

The weather was exceptionally clear and visibility was good as the Olivegrove made her way towards Britain. Von Dresky made towards the merchantman when suddenly, lookouts on the cargo vessel saw the outline of the German submarine coming towards her. There was little chance that the Olivegrove could outpace the German raider, but she turned and took the same course as that of the U-boat and gave off a cover of thick black smoke making it difficult for a torpedo attack. Von Dresky moved in close, and although he wanted to open fire, resisted the temptation after what had happened with the Athenia. 

Under orders of the German Commander in Chief of U-boats Admiral Karl Dönitz, all U-boats were to exercise care when attacking non military naval vessel's. So as he passed the merchant ship he ordered a shot across her bows. The Olivegrove which was unarmed could do nothing but stop her engines and surrender herself to the U-boat. Barnetson knew at once that the U-boat commander would sink his ship, so he ordered all his crew to abandon ship and take to the lifeboats. The U33 kept her position well away from the merchant ship, but close enough to attack the ship, and the Kapitänleutnant waited as the crew of the tramp had all taken to the lifeboats and were well clear before he gave the order to place a torpedo into her amidships. The Olivegrove sank almost immediately after the torpedo warhead exploded and caused further explosions in the engine room before she sank to the bottom.

Von Dresky called to the bobbing lifeboats to come alongside, asked for the ships captain and invited him aboard the U33. The Kapitänleutnant apologised for the loss of the Olivegrove, stating that it was unfortunate that the two countries were at war and that it was his duty to sink the merchant ship, but he assured Captain Barnetson that he would render his crew safe and sated that a radio signal had been sent requesting assistance and to pick up the crew of the Olivegrove. After a short fifteen minute conversation, the two commanders shook hands and Barnetson went back to his lifeboat. For nine hours, the U33 stood by the lifeboats until the shape of an American passenger liner could be seen heading towards them. The German Kapitänleutnant acknowledged his departure with a salute and knowing that the crew of the Olivegrove were now safe started engines and was on his way into to open waters of the Atlantic.

But the gentlemanly conduct of the U-boat commanders was not to last. To Dönitz sea warfare was sea warfare. There were to be no air's and graces in the war at sea and by the following month Dönitz issued the order that all merchant ships that would be recognised as the enemy must be sunk and may be done so without any warning. In addition, all passenger ships, may be torpedoed after due notice has been given and that it was the intention of the U-boat commander to do so.

So far in the war, all civilians were to be spared, and the crews of British merchant vessels, even though they may be carrying materials to be used in the British war effort were being regarded as civilian personnel. The sinking of the Athenia caused furore worldwide, but Dönitz did not see it that way. He issued Standing Order No 154 which read:

You will rescue no one and take no one with you. Have no care for the ships boats, weather conditions and the proximity of land are of no account. Care only for your own boat and strive to achieve the next success as soon as possible. We must be hard in this war. The enemy started the war in order to destroy us, therefore nothing else matters.
Admiral Karl Dönitz 


The Battle of Britain - 1940 website © Battle of Britain Historical Society 2007